Showing posts with label A Good Read. Show all posts
Showing posts with label A Good Read. Show all posts

Monday, November 23, 2009

The Magic Thief: Lost Book Review


The Magic Thief: Lost
Book 2 of The Magic Thief

By Sarah Prineas
Illustrations by Antonio Javier Caparo
Harper Collins Publishers
2009

Dedication: To Theo, because the bird was his idea

Target Age Group: Boys or girls, Ages 10 through 14

Must Read
Good Read
Could Read

Synopsis

Something strange is happening in the city of Welmet. People are turned into stone by shadows. The shadows turn into smoke and disappear. It’s an incomprehensible evil that even the most powerful magicians don’t understand.

Conn, 12 years old, is the magician Nevery’s apprentice. He desperately wants to help, but what every magician needs in order to perform magic is a locus magicalicus – a stone, rock, pebble or jewel – and Conn’s was destroyed. Even without a locus magicalicus, Conn hears the magic speaking to him, but only if there’s an explosion, and he’s banned from exploding anything. Ever.

But what if…only a small explosion…maybe, just maybe…

Book Review

Lost is every bit as enchanting as The Magic Thief book 1. Reading the first book is not necessary to enjoy this one, but I would recommend it.

As with the first book, Lost is told in first person from Conn’s perspective. We get other characters’ perspectives through the use of letters and diaries.

The plot is clever and well thought out and completely believable (if you believe in magic). The pace is good, the mystery mysterious. But mostly, it’s a very enjoyable tale of a boy who’s courageous enough to do the right thing, even when it’s difficult, especially when it’s difficult.

Amazon Links

The Magic Thief: Lost (Hardcover)

Characters

Connwaer – Our hero, he goes by the nickname, Conn. He doesn't really know how old he is, but we're guessing he's between 12 and 14. He’s lived on the streets for a long time, and has quick hands for pick-pocketing, and at least one set of lock-pick wires with him at all times. But more than anything, he's an apprenticed wizard.

Nevery Flinglas – A crusty old -- actually ancient -- wizard who has taken Conn as his apprentice. He believes in Conn and his ability, even if no one else does.

Benet – A tall brutish fellow hired by Nevery as "muscle." But he has several other talents that would surprise you.

Rowan Forestal – Around Conn’s age, she is the daughter of the Duchess of Wellmet. She’s also one of Conn’s very few friends.

Kerrn – Captain of the guards around the Dawn Palace, where Rowan and her mother live. She doesn’t like Conn at all. But how far will she go to stop him from seeing Rowan?

Lord Jaggus – The sorcerer-king of the neighboring town of Desh. He has a ball to greet the envoy from Wellmet, but he hates the tiny lizards that seem to be everywhere in his kingdom.

Sunday, October 11, 2009

The Mousehunter Book Review


The Mousehunter
Written and Illustrated By Alex Milway
Little, Brown and Company
2009
First published in Great Britain in 2008 by Faber and Faber Limited

Dedication: For Katie

Target Age Group: Boys or girls, ages 9 - 12

Must Read
Good Read
Could Read

Synopsis

12 year old Emiline had a dream job. She’s the mousekeeper for Isiah Lovelock, celebrated author of The Mousehunter’s Almanac and one of the richest mouse collectors in the world. He has Sharpclaw mice, Rook-Winged mice, Long-legged River mice, Messenger mice, Howling Scent mice, Whooping Brown mice, Weeping Tearjerker mice, and many, many more.

But what Emiline really wants to be is a mousehunter herself.

When Emiline learns that Isiah has hired Captain Drewshank, his ship and crew to capture the dreaded pirate Mousebeard, Emiline has to be on that ship. This is her chance for adventure.

With her pet Portly, an ordinary Grey mouse, adventure is exactly what she gets, along with sea monsters, capture, lies, curses and a close-up-and-personal encounter with Mousebeard himself.

Book Review

Alex Milway's debut novel is wonderfully charming. Mr. Milway has created an entire world around the concept of mousing – working with mice, cataloging mice, discovering new species of mice – and that the most sought-after careers have to do with this multitude of mice.

The book assumes this is the most natural existence for a society, and the explanations of the various types of mice and their usages in society are simply matter-of-fact.

The story wrapped into this world is engaging, adventurous and funny. It’s the adventure that dreams are made of – to sail the high seas in search of a dreaded pirate.

And with any good story, all is not what it seems.

This is the first book of a trilogy, but a complete and satisfying story in itself.

The illustrations add the perfect imagery to this world. Each chapter begins with a drawing of a specific species of mice, its description from The Mousehunter’s Almanac and Emiline’s notes about it.

The Mousehunter is well-worth the read, and I look forward to the next 2 installments of this trilogy.

Amazon Links

The Mousehunter (Hardback)
The Mousehunter (Paperback)


Characters

Emiline Orelia – 12 years old, and like most kids her age, wants to be a mousehunter. She’s the best mousekeeper around, in spite of the fact that she had only attended Fluffbins’ School of Mousekeeping rather than the prestigious Old Rodent’s Academy.

Isiah Lovelock – The author of The Mousehunter’s Almanac, the most authoritative book on mice ever written. He’s the wealthiest citizen of Old Towne, and has a collection of over 150 mice. But more than anything, he wants the capture of Mousebeard, dreaded pirate of the 17 seas.

Captain Devlin Drewshank – A handsome and striking man, Drewshank is the Captain of the Flying Fox, and a privateer, meaning he takes jobs on the seventeen seas from the highest bidder. And the highest bidder in this story is Isiah Lovelock, who wants him to capture Mousebeard, the dreaded pirate.

Captain Mousebeard – Although that’s not his real name, he’s called Mousebeard because he has several mice living in his massive, hairy beard. He’s a massive man who sends fear into the hearts of all sailors. His exploits are legendary, and he’s managed to evade capture for too many years.

Tuesday, October 6, 2009

The Secret Order of the Gumm Street Girls


The Secret Order of the Gumm Street Girls
Elise Primavera
HarperCollins Publishers
2006
Audio Read By: Colleen Delaney

Dedication: For my father, who is gone but will never leave me.

Target Age Group: Girls between 8 and 12.

Must Read
Good Read
Could Read

Best Experienced: This book can best be experience by either reading the book or listening to the CD.

Benefits of Reading the Book – The book has numerous illustrations throughout, so you get the author’s visualization as well as her textual description of the characters and the scenes.

Benefits of Listening to the CD – The CD is performed by .Colleen Delaney. It’s a very good interpretation of all of the characters in the book. She brings life to the characters.

Synopsis

This is the story of 4 girls, Franny Muggs, Cat Lemmonjello, Prudence (Pru) Gumm, and Ivy Diamond, all around 10 or 11, who live on the same block and attend the same school. You would expect them to be life-long friends, wouldn’t you? They are not. In fact, they don’t even like each other.

The story starts in early April in the whimsical town of Sherbet when Ivy moves into #5 Gumm Street, a ramshackled old house left to her mother by her late Aunt Viola. Ivy’s had a jinx following her for the past 6 years and 10 months because of a broken mirror, and she’s looking forward to a new start in Sherbet, a chance to live a normal life. Ha! Normal lives are for normal girls, and Ivy is anything but normal – she’s special. No, she doesn’t have magic, and she’s not a secret princess -- she is tenacious. When school ends and summer vacation starts, Ivy is in for the adventure of her life, tenacious or not, ready or not. And the other Gumm Street girls are there to help.

Book Review

The first part of the book sets up the town, its inhabitants, and the relationship between all of the girls. But the action really gets started on June 15th – that’s Chapter 11 – with Mr. Staccato’s Piano recital. But don’t skip straight to Chapter 11. The journey to Chapter 11 and afterwards is worth it.

This book weaves in elements from the Wizard of Oz. I generally don’t like stories that are steeped with other stories, as I think it shows a lack of creativity on the part of the author. However, in this case, the characters and the storyline are original enough that the inclusion of the Wizard of Oz enhanced the story rather than detracted from it.

Audio Review

Because this book is about 4 girls, it makes sense to have a woman reading it. Ms. Delaney does a very good job most of the time. The distinction between Pru’s and Cat’s voices was clear. Ivy and Frannie’s voices were not so distinct, particularly Frannie. Ivy had a slight accent, but Frannie’s voice was almost never that distinct.

Amazon Links

The Secret Order of the Gumm Street Girls Paperback

The Secret Order of the Gumm Street Girls CD


Characters

Prudence (Pru) Gumm – Pru lives at #1 Gumm Street. She has round glasses, long dark hair that she twirls in her fingers, or tosses over her shoulders, and she is ultra cautious. She has numerous safety rules that she can quote by number and verse and doesn’t hesitate to do so. She used to be best friends with Cat, but now she thinks Cat is stuck up.

Cat Lemonjello – Cat lives across the street on #2 Gumm Street. She is a tomboy (being the only girl in 11 children), has beautiful blond, shoulder length hair, is good at just about everything, and she has a pony. She likes being better than Pru, no matter what it is, and feels a little guilty about it at the same time. Being the 11th daughter of an 11th daughter, she is said to have ESP and has recently started consulting The Groovy I Ching, a hippie translation of the ancient Chinese I Ching by Cat’s mother. It seems to be like right-on, dude.

Franny Muggs – Franny lives at #3 Gumm Street, next door to Pru and across the street from Cat. Franny can’t play the piano, she can’t do a cartwheel…to be blunt, she’s a klutz. But this doesn’t stop her from wanting to reach the top. Her heroes are Sir Edmund Hillary (the first to climb Mt. Everest) and Amelia Earhart (the first woman to fly solo across the Atlantic). She is never short of ideas, and most importantly, she knows the value of friendship.

Ivy Diamond moves into #5 Gumm Street, the house next door to Franny, at the start of the story, and she is the catalyst for the events that follow. The daughter of a beauty queen, she is thin as a twig with dirty blond hair, a gap in her teeth and ears that poke out. Sadly, she also has a jinx attached to her from a broken mirror. But her 7 years is almost up, and she’s looking forward to a normal life as a normal girl. She couldn’t be more wrong about this – she is very special, with or without the jinx.

Pearl Diamond – Ivy’s mother, a southern belle whose crowning glory was winning the Miss Venus Constellation of Stars beauty pageant, complete with a champagne colored Cadillac. But then the mirror broke, and Ivy got the jinx. Pearl lost everything, including her husband and the Cadillac. The last seven years had been very hard, but Pearl always had a smile and optimistic attitude.

Mr. Staccato – Mr. Staccato lives at #7 Gumm street, next door to Cat and across the street from Pru, Franny and Ivy. He is the piano teacher, who found his way to Sherbet 7 years earlier. I’d like to tell you more, but that would be telling.

Fred and Ginger – Two white, fat little terriers who have an amazing grasp of the English language and frequently mutter to themselves, “Did you ever?” “Never!”

Cha Cha Staccato – She is Mr. Staccato’s sister, no wait, his niece. Actually, she’s probably not related to him at all, but no one in Sherbet needs to know that. Everyone loves Cha Cha, everyone except the Gumm Street girls. And they have a very good reason for not liking her.

Aunt Viola – Aunt Viola was Pearl’s only living relative and the prior owner of #5 Gumm Street. She left the house to Pearl when she passed away.

Hieronymous Gumm – Founder of the Sherbet Academy, he believed every child had a special talent and the God-given right to develop it. That was the basis for Sherbet Academy. Sadly, he died long ago…he did, didn’t he?

Coco and Bling Bling – These are Cha Cha’s nieces, and they’re like, totally mean to the Gumm Street girls. They live in Spoz, more specifically, in the O of Spoz.

Maz – A very tall, very old potato. That’s not an insult, she’s actually a potato! In fact, she’s the oldest potato in Spudz, and as wise as can be. Her knowledge of Spoz and Spudz and

Saturday, September 12, 2009

Silvertongue - Book and Audio Review


Silvertongue

The Stoneheart Trilogy – Book 3

By Charlie Fletcher
Hyperion Books
2009
Hodder Children’s Books (U.K.)
2008
Audio read by Jim Dale

Target Age Group: Boys or girls, Ages 9 through 14

Must Read
Good Read
Should Read

Best Experienced: This book can best be experienced by listening to the CD

Synopsis

Evil has followed George and Edie to London, an evil so old that most of the taints or spits don't even remember it. Its presence stops time and brings a heavy snowfall to London. The only two people alive are George and Edie. The Evil has tipped the balance of power between the spits and the taints, and that means war. George has yet to finish his 3rd duel with the Last Knight, and the stone vine entwining his arm is inching closer and closer to his heart…and death.

Book Review

For most of the story, this book was fabulous, a gut-wrenching, realistic, roller-coaster ride of suspense and adventure as George and Edie battle the new Evil that came back with them at the end of Book 2, and the taints who have always hated them.

That being said, there were two points in the book that, in my opinion, weakened what otherwise would have been a great story.

The first is this: one character laments that his spouse has had an affair. However, the story implies – and George and Edie believe – that the lamenting character has also had an affair. If a man cheats on his wife, he can hardly complain about his wife cheating on him. It’s just not logical.

The second is that the author uses the same plot device that he used at the end of Stoneheart, Book One of the trilogy. While in real life, we are likely to repeat the tricks that have been successful in the past, this is not real life. It’s a story. And in stories, our heroes and heroines are supposed to be more creative, more inventive as the story progresses and they grow. This, more than anything else, brought the book down from being a great story to only being a good story.

Still, read it or listen to it, as there are many, many heart stopping and adventurous moments.

Audio Review

Jim Dale delivers another tour de force performance, bringing all the richness in this story to life.

Amazon Links

Silvertongue (Book 3 of The Stoneheart Trilogy) - Audio CD
Silvertongue (Book 3 of The Stoneheart Trilogy) - Hardback

Ironhand (Book 2 of The Stoneheart Trilogy) - Audio CD
Ironhand (Book 2 of the Stoneheart Trilogy) - Paperback

Stoneheart (Book 1 of The Stoneheart Trilogy) - Audio CD
Stoneheart (Book 1 of The Stoneheart Trilogy) - Paperback

Characters

George Chapman – George is our 12 year old protagonist. He grew up in Book 2 and now must face the evils in London as a man in Book 3, even if he is still just a boy.

Edie – Also 12 years old. She has found her mum’s heartstone, and it still glows. That must mean she’s alive, right? So Edie is going to do everything she can to find her mum, war or no war.

The Gunner – Still the stalwart World War I soldier, protecting Edie and helping George fight the darkness that has taken over London.

The Ice Devil – The evil that escaped from the Frost Fair with George and Edie at the end of Book 2.

The Last Knight – The knight with whom George must have his 3rd and final duel. Except that he’s been consumed by the darkness that escaped from the London stone, an Evil who wants to destroy George in the duel.

Dictionary Johnson – A statue of an 18th century man who wrote a dictionary. In prior books, he herks and jerks, slobbers and twitches. But in Book 3, he manages to find a consistent voice, a friendly cat, and courage to help.

The Red Queen – Riding in her chariot with her two daughters running along side, she received her name as the Red Queen because of the blood she spilled in battle seeking vengence for her daughters. She is the oldest royalty of the spits and can claim leadership over the others.

Spout – A gargoyle who used to be a taint and is now a spit – or at least he’s pledged his loyalty to George. Or has he?

The Raven – A bird loyal to the Walker. He’s been killed several times and always comes back. And he never forgets. Never.

The Magic Thief - Book Review


The Magic Thief
By Sarah Prineas
HarperCollins Publishers
2008
Illustrations by Antonio Javier Caparo

Dedication: To Maud, who laughed in all the right places

Target Age Group: Boys or Girls, ages 10 to 14

Must Read
Good Read
Should Read

Synopsis

Someone is stealing all the magic from the town of Wellmet. Nevery, a magician banished from Wellmet 20 years ago, has been called back to solve the mystery.

Enter Conn, a boy between 12 and 14 years old, orphaned, hungry and a thief. When he hears a cane tapping on a dark rainy night, he figures the old man’s purse will pay for his dinner. But what he steals isn’t money – it’s Nevery's locus magicalicus, a stone that helps a magician focus his spells.

Conn knows he’s in big trouble, he just doesn’t realize how much trouble. But from that moment on, his life will never be the same.

Book Review

After a summer of reading more than one disappointing book (none of which will be reviewed here), The Magic Thief was a delightful surprise. It was fun, creative and engaging.

Told in first person from Conn’s point of view, the author give us other characters’ perspectives by using letters and a diary. This technique is very effective.

But Conn’s journey is the main reason to read this book. He’s a wonderful character you’d love to have pick your pocket.

This is Sarah Prineas's debut novel. Her second novel in this series, The Magic Thief: Lost, has recently been released.

Amazon Links

The Magic Thief (Book 1 in Paperback)
The Magic Thief: Lost (Book 2 of The Magic Thief) - Hardback

Characters

Connwaer – Our hero, he goes by the nickname, Conn. He doesn't really know how old he is, but we're guessing he's between 12 and 14. He’s lived on the streets for a long time, and has quick hands for pick-pocketing, and at least one set of lock-pick wires with him at all times.

Nevery Flinglas – The crusty old wizard whose locus magicalicus Conn stole. Nevery has returned to Wellmet after 20 years' banishment to help the other wizards discover what is happening to Wellmet’s slowly disappearing magic.

Benet – A tall brutish fellow hired by Nevery as "muscle." But he has several other talents that would surprise you.

Brumbee – A fat man, Brubmee is a wizard and the Master of Wellmet Academicos. He is also the person who asked Nevery to come back to Wellmet to help solve the problem of the disappearing magic.

Rowan Forestal – A tall girl, 15 year old, without any magical powers sitting in on the magician’s apprentice classes at Wellmet Academicos. She’s been assigned as Conn’s tutor.

Keeston – The best apprentice at Wellmet Academicos, he’s big and proud, and doesn’t think that Conn should be anyone’s apprentice.

Underlord Crowe – The villain of our story. As Conn says, "Only one thing ever happened to anybody who crossed the Underlord. And it involved weights and chains and the river on a dark night.”

Wednesday, April 15, 2009

Thornspell - Book Review


Thornspell
By Helen Lowe
Alfred A. Knopf
An imprint of Random House Children's Books
2008

Dedication: To Andrew, who never doubted.

Target Age Group: Boys or girls, 9 through 14

Must Read
Good Read
Should Read

Synopsis

Sigismund is the crown prince of his country, left with caretakers in the west castle while his father, the king, battles a rebellion in the south. Life as a crown prince in this isolated part of the world is very lonely, and young Sigismund dreams of daring quests and adventures, like Parsifal and the grail quest or King Arthur’s court. Next to his castle is an enchanted Wood, with an interdict placed by Sigismund’s great-grandfather that no one ever go there. Ever. But why? It’s been nearly 100 years, and no one remembers.

When Sigismund is visited by the mysterious Margravine zu Malvolin, his world begins to change, as he is part of the powerful magic that has protected the Wood for nearly 100 years. But what is Sigismund’s role in the magic? Who can he trust, and who are his enemies? When 100 years are up, will Sigismund be able to save a sleeping princess trapped in the Wood? Or will he be defeated before he even has the chance?

Book Review

This is a wonderful book destined to become a fairytale classic. The entire story is told in close third person from Sigismund’s point of view. We follow his life from around 12 years old through young adulthood, when he must face his own quest to save the princess in the castle hidden in the heart of the enchanted Wood.

The characters are colorful and the story suspenseful, with action and mystery throughout. I can easily see this book becoming a successful movie. If your taste in books includes fairytales, then this story is for you.

Characters

Sigismund – Crown prince, and in fact the only son of the King. He has lived a protected life in the west castle since his mother died and his father brought him there. He dreams of going on grand quests, defeating opponents and righting wrongs.

Margravine zu Malvolin – A chance visitor to Sigismund’s castle, having inherited a castle nearby. But her meeting was anything than chance, and she sets the adventure into motion. The question is, is she friend or foe?

Master Griff – Sigismund’s tutor. He doesn’t believe in magic and thinks that Sigismund is getting too old to believe in these stories as well.

Balisan – Sigismund’s master-at-arms, sent to Sigismund by the King to train him. Balisan is from the eastern part of the kingdom, where all the hero-knights are from. He not only believes in magic, he is magical.

Florian Langrafon – Also known as Flor. Sigismund meets him when he moves to the main castle in the country’s capital city. He is about Sigismund’s age and becomes his best friend. The Langrafons are a noble family, and being nobility, Flor believes that he is above the servants in the castle.

Wat and Wenceslas – Cousins who work in the stables in the west castle. Because of the remoteness of the castle and the lack of boys Sigismund’s age, Sigismund becomes friends with both Wat and Wenceslas, even though they are his servants.

Rue – A mysterious girl, mute, probably a servant, wearing a ragged skirt that showed bare ankles. She turns up in Sigismund’s life at the most unexpected moments. But can he trust her? Or is she his enemy? As much as Balison knows of the people surrounding Sigismund, he has never heard of this girl before.

Saturday, April 4, 2009

Sword of Waters - Book Review


Sword of Waters
The Shield, Sword and Crown Trilogy – Book 2

By Hilari Bell
Simon and Schuster Books for Young Readers
2008

Dedication: The Wildfolk have been my writers group for almost a quarter of a century now. They’re the people who tell me when my beginning is too confusing, when my climax has the wrong people solving the problems, and when I desperately need to add a murder and a subplot – and that’s just with this trilogy! These are the people who taught me how to write, and I would never have done it without them. So this book is dedicated to the Wildfolk, all of you, past present and to come.

Target Age Group: Girls, 10 through 15

Must Read
Good Read
Should Read

Synopsis

14 year old Arisa should be happy. The rebellion she spent her entire life working for has succeeded. She now lives in the palace and is part of the royal court. And she’s never felt more useless and lost in her life. So when she discovers some muddy footprints on her balcony, her curiosity is piqued. Is this a conspiracy? Or is it just a servant sneaking out for a romantic evening?

In trying to find out, Arisa is unwittingly plunged into a dangerous game of intrigue, deception and betrayal. When she turns to her two friends for help – Weasel and Prince Edoran – she may have put them all in danger. Because someone wants them dead.

Book Review

Book 1 of this trilogy, Shield of Stars, is one of my favorite books. This book Sword of Waters, begins one month after the conclusion of Shield of Stars.

Shield of Stars was Weasel’s story, his desperate attempts to save the life of Justice Holis, a man he dearly loves. This is Arisa’s story, told in close third person from Arisa’s perspective.

And it is a wonderful story, full of surprises, unexpected twists and turns. You may not agree with the choices that Arisa makes, but you understand why she does what she does. To tell you more would be…well, telling.

Read Shield of Stars, then read Sword of Waters. And hope that the third book, Crown of Earth, comes out very, very soon!

Characters

Arisa Benison – Our 14 year old heroine. She grew up in the countryside in Deorthas, around thieves and bandits who opposed the evil Regent Pettibone. Now she lives in the palace and must learn to be a lady. But she'd rather be wearing britches and working on her skills with a knife and blade.

Weasel – Also 14 years old. He was Justice Holis’s clerk, but now he spends most of his time with Prince Edoran. But he doesn’t let his skills as a former pickpocket and lock pick go to waste. Especially when Arisa asks for his help.

Prince Edoran – The 15 year old prince of Deorthas, he is a complex young man with hidden talents of his own. He’s obsessed with proving that his father’s death wasn’t an accident. He and Weasel are good friends. In fact Weasel is probably the best friend he’s ever had. But what about Arisa? She makes no bones about how she feels about him. But what does he think about her?

Regent Holis – Formerly Justice Holis, he has taken the role of Regent until Edoran comes of age and becomes king. He’s a man of wisdom and the law, and rules fairly, but he’s made his share of enemies.

Lady Benison – Arisa’s mother. She is in charge of the Navy, a position second only to the Regent. She has her share of enemies as well. She wants Arisa to spend more time with the prince.

Katrin – Arisa’s maid. Her family has been connected to the palace for over 6 generations, so she knows how Arisa should dress. That includes corsets, no matter how tight, and definitely does not include britches.

Sunday, March 22, 2009

Gullstruck Island - Book Review


Gullstruck Island
By Frances Hardinge
Macmillan Children’s Books
2009


Dedication: To my sister Sophie, a truer traveler than I shall ever be, who saved lives when others were seeing sights, and who brought back tropical diseases and broken bones instead of photos and souvenir hats

Target Age Group: Girls, 10 – 15 years old

Must Read
Good Read
Should Read

Synopsis

13 year old Arilou is a member of the Lace tribe, the indigenous tribe of Gullstruck Island, a tribe that is not trusted by any of the other settlers who live on the island.

But Arilou is also a Lost, which means that she can send her senses away from her body to see or hear events elsewhere on the island. A Lost is revered, and people come from miles around to see Arilou. Their visits provide her poverty-stricken village of Hollow Beasts with enough food and goods to survive, and keep them safe from the suspicious whispers of the surrounding non-Lace villagers.

But there’s a problem. Maybe Arilou isn’t Lost at all, maybe she’s really just an imbecile, something her entire village of Hollow Beasts suspects.

Arilou is cared for by her younger sister, 12 year old Hathin. Hathin interprets Arilou’s mutterings for the people who come to visit.

Life at Hollow Beasts takes a radical turn when Raglan Skein, a Lost Inspector, comes to the village to test Arilou. If he finds that Arilou is not a Lost, then Hollow Beasts will not survive. The entire village is depending on Hathin to deceive Inspector Skein so that Arilou passes the test.

But tragedy strikes during Inspector Skein’s visit. Is it murder? Natural death? Coincidence? Or conspiracy?

Suddenly, Hathin and Arilou are plunged into chaos and become the central figures of island-wide hunt. Because if Arilou really is a Lost, she might know what the truth is.


Book Review

Gullstruck Island is a slow-starting book. The first few chapters spend a considerable amount of time describing the history of the island, the people who live on it, the relationships between its inhabitants and the languages they speak. It goes into great detail about each group’s customs and habits, which are vastly different. And it introduces a number of characters – a LOT of characters, whom I had trouble keeping straight.

I started reading Gullstruck Island right after Eon Dragoneye Reborn, which captured me from the first page, and I was pretty disappointed at this book’s slow pace.

But I’m glad I stayed with it. Once past the history lesson, the story is rich, complex and surprising. For me, the true enjoyment of the book started around Chapter 8. After Chapter 12, I was hooked and found it hard to put the book down.

The complexity of Gullstruck Island’s story is similar to Ms. Hardinge’s first book, Fly By Night (which remains one of my favorites), in that there is more than one force at play, and the bad seed at the root of the trouble is not at all what I expected. If you’re willing to wade through a muddish start, then this book delivers a very good story.

Characters

Hathin – 12 years old, and the heroine of the story. She is Arilou’s little sister, whose sole purpose for living to is to take care of her sister and perpetuate the belief that Arilou is a Lost. Hathin is a Lace, with a trace of pirate in her ancestry.

Arilou – 13 years old, and the Lady Lost of Hollow Beasts. Although Arilou showed signs of being a Lost as an infant, they disappeared without a trace. In spite of years or trying, Hathin has never been able to make sense of Arilou’s mutterings.

Raglan Skein – The inspector who comes to Hollow Beasts to test Arilou. He is a Lost, of mixed heritage, but more of the Cavalcaste blood than Lace. He is also on the Lost Council, the body that governs all the Lost. He fears a dangerous conspiracy. Is that why he’s testing Arilou? Or is there some other reason?

Minchard Prox – The official governmental aide to Inspector Skein, of Cavalcaste descent. Like many of the Cavalcaste clans, he is extremely suspicious of the Lace. He wants to test Arilou and leave Hollow Beasts as soon as possible. But fate has other plans for him.

Whish – A member of the Lace tribe in Hollow Beasts. Whish holds a grudge against Hathin & Arilou’s family. Is it enough for her to betray them?

Larsh – A Lace master craftsman. Like all Lace in Hollow Beasts, he knows that Arilou may not be a Lost. But he too has a secret that has been well-hidden.

Therrot – Whish’s son. He left Hollow Beasts two years earlier on a revenge quest, persuaded by Hathin’s oldest sister, and has not been seen or heard from since.

Milady Page – She is the Lady Lost in the nearby village of Sweetwater. She is Cavelcaste, and constantly sending her senses out and returning with news from other villages. Like others, she is suspicious of the Lace, and she tells them she's keeping an eye on them. Is is possible that she know about Arilou?

Jimboly – Not Lace, not Cavalcaste, but a mixture of other races, Jimboly is a dentist. She pulls teeth for free, keeping the teeth themselves as payment. Unlike most non-Lace, she actually smiles, and when she smiles, it’s impossible not to like her. But why does she keep a bird tethered to her at all times?

Brendril – An Ashwalker, descended from the tribe of Dancing Steam. They get their powers by dying their clothes with the ashes of the dead. They are deadly hunters who never, ever give up, once they’ve been given a commission to hunt a murderer.

Dance – Leader of the Reckoning, a band of Lost who have taken revenge oaths when the Cavalcaste government fails to provide justice to Lace. Therrot left Hollow Beasts to join the Reckoning to seek revenge for his little sister’s death.

Superior Pedron Sun-Sedrollo – The Cavalcaste Superior of the town of Jealousy, whose sole purpose in life is to make sure his dead ancestors have everything they need. But what does this have to do with the Lace or the Lost?

Saturday, March 7, 2009

Dragon Flight - Book Review


Dragon Flight
By Jessica Day George
Bloomsbury U.S.A. Children’s Books
2008

Dedication: For my own curious little monkey, who already loves books and whose naps made it possible for this one to be written

Target Age Group: Girls, ages 10 through 14

Must Read
Good Read
Should Read

Synopsis

Creel was named Heroine of the Dragon Wars for her help in saving Feravel in the book, Dragon Slippers. As her reward, she got her heart’s desire – not marriage to Crown Prince Miles, but her own dress shop!

She is very happy. That is, until she gets news from her good friend, Prince Luka, that the neighboring country of Citatie has declared war on Feravel. And their soldiers are all mounted on dragons.

Creel is brought into King Caxel’s council as the “dragon expert.” But can she persuade the dragons to help them? After all, dragons don’t want to get involved with human affairs. But if that’s true, then why are the dragon’s helping the soldiers of Citatie?

None of it makes sense, but all of it makes for an unforgettable adventure.

Book Review

The first story, Dragon Slippers, was such a perfect story – beginning, middle, end – that I wasn’t sure what a sequel would be like, although I liked the characters in Dragon Slippers and was happy to get reacquainted with them. Still, I was a bit skeptical about whether this would be a good story.

I quickly realized that I was wrong. Dragon Flight was just as enjoyable as Dragon Slippers.

As with Dragon Slippers, Dragon Flight is told in first person from Creel’s point of view. She’s just as outspoken in this adventure as she was in Dragon Slippers. Only this time, the stakes are higher.

Characters

Creelisel Carlbrun (Creel) – Creel is another year older and another year wiser. She owns her dress shop, a dream come true for her. But her friendship with the dragons makes her exceptionally valuable to King Caxel.

Prince Luka – The younger son of King Caxel. He’s about Creel’s age, and her good friend. Maybe even her boyfriend? He writes her frequently while he is in Citatie as Feravel’s envoy.

Shardas and Velika – King and queen of the dragons. Everyone thinks they are dead, everyone except Creel, Luka and Marta.

Amacarin, Finiul and Niva – Three dragons who are loyal to King Shardas and Queen Velika. None of them are interested in helping humans in their war.

Earl Sarryck – The commander of the Feravelan army, he doesn’t believe that the dragons are more than ignorant beasts, and the best way to deal with them is to exterminate them. But can he persuade King Caxel?

King Nason – King of Citatie. He always wears a helmet, even when he sleeps. He believes that a king should never bear his head before his underlings. But is that the real reason why he wears it?

Lord Arjas – The Grand Vizier of Citatie (the equivalent of our Secretary of State). He makes sure that King Nason keeps his helmet on. After all, that’s what the king wants, right?

Krashath – A large white dragon, and apparently King Nason’s pet. He sleeps behind the King’s throne. But he has a secret, one that he shares with Creel…right before he kidnaps her.

Dragon Slippers - Book Review



Dragon Slippers
By Jessica Day George
Bloomsbury U.S.A. Children’s Books
2007

Dedication: For Mikey, who has put up with an awful lot over the past nine years, but who never gave up on me or let me give up on myself.

And for the dragons.

Target Age Group: Girls, ages 10 through 14

Must Read
Good Read
Should Read

Synopsis

Creel and her brother are orphans, left in the care of her aunt and uncle, who are as poor as their parents had been. Creel’s aunt has a wonderful idea: Creel should be captured by a dragon (a dragon who, by the way, hasn’t been seen in two generations). She’ll be rescued by a noble knight, and taken to live happily ever after in the knight’s castle (where her entire family will join them, of course).

But an old, brown dragon named Theoradus does show up. And he does capture Creel. He just doesn’t want to fight. After all, it’s too easy for a dragon to roast a knight inside his armor. So Creel offers to help. She will make sure Theoradus doesn’t have to fight the knight if she can have one item from the dragon’s hoard. Theoradus agrees.

Creel is disappointed to find out that this dragon’s hoard isn't gold or jewels, but shoes. That's right, this dragon collects shoes. Oh well, a deal is a deal, so Creel selects a comfortable pair of shoes from the hundreds that Theoradus has.

What Creel doesn’t know, and what the dragons don’t tell her, is how special this particular pair of shoes is.

Creel bids farewell to Theoradus to travel to King’s Seat, the largest town in her country of Feravel, where she plans to open her own dress shop. She thinks she will never see Theoradus or any other dragons again. But she couldn’t be more wrong. Instead of her own dress shop, Creel finds adventure, intrigue, a charming prince, a spoiled princess, true friendship and stunning betrayal.

Book Review

I loved this book. It’s told in first person from Creel’s perspective. She frequently adds her own comments to the narrative. And what’s wrong with that? She calls a spade a spade, but unfortunately, her tongue tends to get her in more trouble then she intends.

This is Jessica Day George’s first novel, and while it was originally intended to be a book on its own, it has become the first book of the Dragon Slippers Trilogy.

Characters

Creelisel Carlbrun (Creel) – 15 years old and the heroine of our story. Creel has straw-yellow hair that’s also straw-straight, blue eyes and a small, freckled nose. From Carlieff Town, she doesn’t realize how much of a country girl she is, until she meets the Princess Amalia.

Theoradus – A brown dragon, 670 years old who lives in Carlieff Town. He’s fought a few knights in his younger days but has no desire to do so any longer. He just wants to be left in peace, with his cherished collection of shoes.

Shardas – A golden dragon, living near King’s Seat. He’s a full century older than Theoradus, but far more active. He collects windows, and has a secret he keeps from Creel.

Luka Mulin – The younger son of King Caxel. He’s around Creel’s age, and appreciates her honesty.

Miles Mulin – The crown prince of Feravel, which means he’s the older son of King Caxel and next in line for the throne. His engagement to Amalia was rather sudden, and not everyone in King’s Seat is happy about it. But it’s a royal match designed to keep peace between their two countries.

Amalia – The princess of Roulain. She’s a petulant brat with a yippy dog. She wants Creel’s shoes. After all, why should a country girl from Carlieff Town have such fine shoes? And why can’t she -- a princess -- just take them if she wants to?

Derda – The proprietress of an extremely fine dress shop in King’s Seat. She agrees to give Creel work, as long as Creel can keep a civil tongue.

Marta, Larkin and Alle – The other girls who work in Derda’s shop. They appear to like Creel, but are they really her friends? Or will they use her to get ahead themselves?

Wednesday, March 4, 2009

Shield of Stars - Book Review


Shield of Stars
The Shield, Sword and Crown Trilogy – Book 1

By Hilari Bell
Simon and Schuster Books for Young Readers
2007

Dedication: To Joyce and William Griffen, aka Aunt Kelly and Uncle Bill, who have cared about my writing since the beginning

Target Age Group: Boys or Girls, ages 9 through 14

Must Read
Good Read
Should Read


Synopsis

Weasel was an 11-year-old orphaned boy living in the medieval country of Deorthas whose only means of survival was as a pickpocket. Until one day when he picked Judge Holis’s pocket. Judge Holis gave Weasel the opportunity to become his clerk, and Weasel accepted, knowing the alternative was jail, or possibly hanging. In the last 3 years, Weasel lived with Judge Holis, became a very good clerk and found, for some unexplained reason, that not disappointing Judge Holis had become very important to him.

So when the judge is arrested for treason, Weasel will do anything to help him, including joining forces with the Falcon, a dangerous bandit. In his quest, Weasel meets Arisa, a mysterious girl who agrees to help him.

At stake is not only Judge Holis’s life, but the future of Deorthas, whose young, 15-year-old Prince Edoran is controlled by the manipulative and power-hungry Regent Pettibone. Who has the right to control the country? Legend has it that the sword and shield were symbols of the true king of Deorthas, but they were lost centuries ago, allegedly in a game of cards.

So what do the sword and shield have to do with Weasel and his quest to free Judge Holis? Everything.

Review

This is an excellent book, full of surprises. It was the first book by Hilari Bell that I read, and it hooked me. I couldn’t put it down. Her other books are very good, but this one stayed with me long after I read it. The characters are full and rich, very believable. I can’t wait until the next book in the trilogy!

Characters

Weasel – Our protagonist, a 14-year-old former pick-pocket who has reformed at the strong suggestion of Judge Holis, who makes Weasel his clerk. Weasel’s future looks more and more like it will be as a law clerk, but Weasel has a back-up plan – to work as a forger. After all, everyone needs options.

Judge Holis – An elderly judge who wants to see justice in his country. He fears for the country because Regent Pettibone has such a strong influence over Prince Edoran. He plans a legal change of power, but is arrested for treason instead.

Prince Edoran – 15 years old and will be king when he comes of age. But for now, he’s far too young to rule the country. Particularly when he can barely read. But not to worry, Regent Pettibone will make all the right decisions for him.

Regent Pettibone – Since the prince is not yet of age, he needs someone to guide him, help him make the right decisions. Regent Pettibone is just the man for the job. And make sure you don’t cross him or get in his way…or else.

Arisa Benison – About Weasel’s age, Arisa was a prisoner in the storeroom that Weasel was placed in when he was arrested. When Weasel escapes, she’s not about to be left behind. But is she going to help him? Or betray him?

Falcon – The country’s most dangerous bandit, although it’s rumored that the country folk don’t see him that way. They see him as someone who can stand up to Regent Pettibone. Will he bring his armies to the city to help rescue Judge Holis? Will Weasel even be able to find him?

Saturday, February 28, 2009

The Last Dragon - Book Review


The Last Dragon
(entitled The Last Elf in the original Italian book)
By Silvana De Mari
Adriano Salani Editore, Milan
2004
Published in U.S. by Hyperion Books for Children, 2006
Translated from Italian to English by Shaun Whiteside

Dedication: For my father, who showed me the way, even if he had lost his

Target Age Group: Boys or Girls ages 9 through 12

Must Read
Good Read
Should Read

Synopsis

Yorsh is an elf, one born lately, meaning he’s a child. Sometime in his recent past, his home – a camp where elves are forced to live – was flooded by the unbearable and unstoppable rain, rain that humans blame on the elves. After wandering through the woods, cold, hungry and alone, the elf meets Sajra and Monser. He also discovers a prophecy:

When the last dragon and the last elf break the cirle, the past and the future will meet, and the sun of a new summer will shine in the sky.

Yorsh realizes that he is the last elf, that the prophecy is about him. With Sajra and Monser's help, he goes in search of the last dragon to fulfill his destiny.

Book Review

This is a wonderful story, full of both funny and tender moments. It’s well written and told well. However, the title is a bit misleading. The story is more about Yorsh and his destiny than it is about the Erbrow, the dragon.

The book is in two parts. The first part lays out the rains that plague the land, the cruel rule in the city of Daligar, Yorsh’s simple understanding of humans, and his relationship with Sajra and Monser.

The second part is the heart of the story, which takes place 13 years later. Yorsh has grown into a very handsome elf. Erbrow is an arrogant dragon, but he has his moments. They go to seek their destiny, which was laid out in the prophecy.

This is a wonderful adventure that can be enjoyed by the entire family.

Characters

Yorshkrunsquarkljolnerstrink – Just call him Yorsh. He is an elf, the very last elf. Since English isn’t his first language, he sometimes has difficulty understanding what a human is really telling him. For example, when Sajra says, "I'm a woman, fool!" he immediately calls her woman-fool. After all, that's what she said.

Sajra – An ordinary woman who has a very large and kind heart. She tries to stay out of trouble, but that just doesn’t seem to happen very often. We don't know much about where she came from, all we know is that she struggles every day to find somewhere dry to sleep and something -- anything at all -- to eat. The one thing that she does have is a flame.

Monser – A hunter and a kind man. All he wants from Sajra is to share her flame. If she shares it, he will be on his way. But he has a big heart and finds he can't leave Sajra -- she simply gets in too much trouble. But keeping her and Yorsh out of trouble is not an easy task.

Fido – Fido is (surprise!) a dog. Named by Yorsh because he is faithful and has fidelity. Monser thinks it's a ridiculous name for a dog, but it's more appropriate than Monser will ever know.

Dragon – Too old to remember his name, this is the last dragon of the prophecy. Or is he? As dragons go, this one is pretty pathetic. Yorsh feels this dragon is, “stupid, tiresome, bossy and unbearable.”

Erbrow – This is the last dragon. This is the last one, right? Or was it the other dragon? This dragon is an insufferable know-it-all. But he loves his elf-brother, Yorsh.

Robi – An orphan girl. But why is she an orphan? And what does she have to do with the prophecy?

Mistress Phlesh and Master Slump – The proprietors of the orphange where Robi lives. They’re just as you would expect them to be: stingy, selfish, mean and stupid.

Clover and Beach – Two of Daligar’s prison guards. They’re very loyal and fearsome guards…aren’t they?

Monday, February 23, 2009

Dragon Rider - Book and Audio Review


Dragon Rider
By Cornelia Funke
Cecilie Dressler Verlag, Hamburg (under the title Drachenreiter)
1997
First published in the U.K. in 2004 by The Chicken House
First published in the U.S. in September 2004 by Scholastic
Translated from German to English by Anthea Bell
Audio read by Brendan Fraser

Dedication: For Uwe Weitendorf

Target Age Group: Boys or girls, ages 8 to 11 years old

Must Read
Good Read
Should Read

Best Experienced: This story can best be experience by either reading the book or listening to the CD. With the book, you can see Ms. Funke’s illustrations. But with the CD, you get a great performance by Brendan Fraser.

Synopsis

Dragons have been hiding from humans for years in caves on the hills that surround a peaceful valley. But Rat brings distressing news: humans are coming to the valley to turn it into a reservoir, and the dragons have to leave.

But where can they go? There aren’t many places left in the world for a dragon to hide, and they are all tired of hiding. A young dragon named Firedrake volunteers to go in search of the Rim of Heaven, the place where the dragons came from so many years ago – a place that many of the dragons believe is mythical.

Sorrel, a brownie girl and Firedrake’s devoted friend, insists on going with him on the journey. Along the way, they meet Ben, a orphaned boy (the dragon rider), rats with maps, humans who try to kill them and humans who don’t, and most dangerous of all, Nettlebrand, the golden one, who hunts dragons for fun and food.

Book Review

Dragon Rider is a classic “quest” adventure, where the heroes of the story – Firedrake, Sorrel and Ben – are on a quest to find the Rim of Heaven, a oft-thought mythical place where dragons can fly free of human influence. But is the Rim of Heaven a real place? Or is it a mythical place of old dragon fairy tales?

Firedrake believes it’s real. Of course, there would be no story if our heroes didn’t meet with challenges, road-blocks and a number of interesting characters along the way.

Dragon Rider is, very simply, a charming story, and a great story to read to kids at bedtime.

Audio Review

I wasn’t sure what to expect from Brendan Fraser’s performance. Of course, on-screen, he can do no wrong, but reading a book? I wasn’t so sure.

I was in for a delightful surprise. He reads the story as if it’s a bedtime story, with great character voices and adding sound effects to the scenes. I found myself laughing a lot, and occasionally crying. Listening to this book is a treasure in itself.

Characters

Firedrake – a young dragon who volunteers to go find the Rim of Heaven. He’s fair, honest, and would risk his life for a friend. In short, he’s the kind of dragon you want to have on an adventure like this.

Sorrel – A girl forest brownie. Forest brownies are known for their love of mushrooms and their crankiness. Sorrel is no exception. And even though she doesn’t believe in the Rim of Heaven, she’s a faithful friend to Firedrake and goes with him.

Ben – The dragon rider. He’s an orphaned boy, living on his own in a warehouse. But then he meets Firedrake, a real dragon! The offer to come and help them search for the Rim of Heaven is too much for him to pass up. After all, no one would miss him anyway.

Twigleg – a Humunculus, which means he looks like a little human being, but he was created by an alchemist. He had 11 brothers, who were all eaten by his master, Nettlebrand. Because he’s so small, he would be the perfect spy for Nettlebrand.

Nettlebrand – also known as the Golden One. Nettlebrand is a golden dragon who can’t fly, and who hunts the silver dragons. Only there hasn’t been a silver dragon seen for over 100 years. Until he learns about Firedrake. Yum, yum, Nettlebrand is looking forward to a good meal!

Barnabas Greenbloom – A professor who happens to believe in fantastic and magical creatures, having met many of them. But a real brownie! And a real dragon! He is more than honored to meet them.

Gravelbeard – A particularly greedy mountain dwarf. After Twigleg becomes Nettlebrand’s spy, Gravelbeard takes over as Nettlebrand’s armor polisher, not because he likes to polish, but because he’s been promised gold. And he would do anything for gold.

Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Half Moon Investigations - Book and Audio Review


Half Moon Investigations
By Eoin Colfer
Hyperion Books for Children
2006
Audio read by Sean Patrick Reilly

Dedication: To Liam and John: The Thursday-Night Think Tank

Target Age Group: Boys or Girls, Ages 10 - 14

Must Read
Good Read
Should Read

Best Experienced: This book is best experienced by listening to the CD.

Synopsis

Fletcher Moon – also known as Half Moon because of his size – is a born detective, licensed to practice in Washington, D.C. … when he’s 21. But for now, he’s 12 years old living with his family in Lock, Ireland. Fletcher is looking for his first real case, his first paying customer. He finds it in the form of 10 year old April Devereux, queen Barbie to a tribe of pink-clad Barbies. Something of hers is missing, and she wants to get it back. Fletcher’s cherished detective’s badge is also missing, and he thinks the same person who stole his badge – Red Sharkey – stole from April as well. This motivates him to take the case, where he will retrieve his badge and bring down the Sharkey crime family in the process. But like most mysteries, things are not exactly as they seem.

Book Review

Half Moon Investigations is told in first-person, from Fletcher’s perspective. The entire book has the tone of a cheesy, 1930’s, hard-boiled detective movie, and it’s done to perfection. While this book is generally not the type of book I read – there’s no magic in it at all – it had a sense of whimsy that I love when I read a book.

One of the things that I really liked about it was the seriousness that it treated the things that these kids care about -- the loss of a mini-disk, phonograph needles, and a lock of a star's hair that was purchased on e-bay. None of these disappearances is worth a policeman's time, but to Fletcher Moon, it's serious business, very serious.

This is the first, and so far the only book in the Half Moon Investigations series, but the end of the book hinted at more. Perhaps the “more” is in the form of a TV series, which the BBC currently has in production. Still, I would gladly welcome another adventure in book form.

Audio Review

Sean Patrick Reilly has captured the tone of this story to perfection. He really brought the story alive. Often, the adventure of a book is as accessible by reading as it is by listing to the CD, but in this case, I think the CD performance really gives the book its life.

Characters

Fletcher Moon – Also known as Half Moon because of his stature, or rather lack of stature. Our hero, currently 12 years old, has been a genuine detective since the age of 11 when he graduated first in his class from the Bernstein Academy in Washington, D.C. via an online course. He even has a real detective’s badge. Badge or not, Fletcher was born to be a detective, having solved his first case at age 3. He loves a mystery and has the wit and imagination to solve it.

Hazel Moon – Fletcher’s 15 year old sister, and a drama queen. She doesn’t hesitate to embarrass Fletcher – that’s an older sister’s job – but she can keep his secrets, too…for a price.

April Devereux – April is 10 years old and the epitome of a Barbie doll. She is also the head of Les Jeunes Etudiantes, a club with all the other Barbies from school. From a well-to-do family, her parents deny her nothing. She’s used to getting what she wants, and what she wants is for Fletcher to work for her to solve her mystery.

May Devereux – April’s first cousin and the object of Fletcher Moon’s budding affection. She's also in Les Jeunes Etudiantes, and she's planning to do a Riverdance for the upcoming talent show. Wish her lots of luck, because she will need it.

Herod Sharkey – 10 years old, nicknamed Roddy, one of the Sharkey family kids, and a one-kid crime wave himself. If anything’s missing, it was probably a Sharkey, and most likely Herod was involved.

Red Sharkey – 14 years old and still in the 8th grade. His flaming red hair – a Sharkey signature – is the source of his nickname. No one knows his real name, except perhaps his father. No matter what you call him, Red is cool...very cool. But he’s a Sharkey, and that means he’s probably trouble.

Murt Hourihan – Murt is a Sergeant on the Lock police force, and a friend of Fletcher’s. He thinks that Fletcher has potential, but doesn’t really take him seriously – a mistake, he’s not likely to make again.

Principal Quinn – Principal of Saint Jerome’s School, Mrs. Quinn is usually accompanied by her two dobermans, Larry and Adam. She keeps a ledger of every child who has ever been in Saint Jerome’s, in which she draws pictures to depict the type of person the student is, including the flames of Hell, which is where she fears Fletcher is heading.

Wednesday, February 11, 2009

Stoneheart - Book and Audio Review


Stoneheart
The Stoneheart Trilogy - Book One

By Charlie Fletcher
Hodder Children’s Books (U.K.)
2006
First U.S. Edition 2007
Hyperion Books for Children
Audio read by Jim Dale

Dedication: With love and thanks to my parents, Margaret and Paul Fletcher, makers of a happy childhood and much else besides…

Target Age Group: Boys ages 11 and above

Must Read
Good Read
Should Read

Recommendation: Read the Book or Listen to the CD

Synopsis

12 year old George Chapman is a sad, lonely boy without a father, and with a mother who spends more time on her acting career than with her son. At school, he’s picked on and bullied by students and teachers alike.

After a disasterous trip to the Natural History Museum, George unleashes all of his anger and frustration onto a small stone dragon, breaking its head off a frieze. In doing so, George has unwittingly awakened the fury of all the stone statues in London. Gargoyles, dragons and pterodactyls come to life to seek their revenge on George.

As George runs across London for his life, he quickly realizes that no one else can see the statues chasing him. No one, except Edie, a strange girl who has unexplained powers of her own. Together, with the help of some “spits,” George and Edie have to figure out how to appease the angry “taints.”

Book Review

The book starts out so dark and moody that it was difficult for me to get into. I didn’t much care for either George or Edie. I found it very annoying that for a first part of the book, the "spits" acknowledge that the "taints" are riled up and that George has done something, but no one bothers to asks George what happened, when it started, what he did.

However, I am more than glad I stayed with the story. Charlie Fletcher uses words as effectively as a painter does colors, and delivers gloriously realistic scenes. You feel that you are in London, seeing what George and Edie see, feeling what they feel. And as I got to know these two kids, I began to appreciate what they’ve each suffered individually, and started to cheer them as they grow beyond their circumstances to change into caring people. By the time the story was over, I couldn’t wait for the next one.

Audio Review

The audio book is read by the incomparable Jim Dale. He brings every character to life, each with a different voice. His characters are so distinct that there is no confusion as to who is speaking. When I'm listening to CD, I frequently forget that there is only one man reading. Rather, I feel like I am experiencing these people’s lives and voices.

Characters

George Chapman – George is 12 years old and seriously depressed since the separation of his parents and death of his father. He desperately wants to belong somewhere and doesn’t fit in anywhere.

Edie – 12 years old as well, she’s a runaway with a murky past. Her father is also dead, and her mother is not around, although we don't really know what has happened to her. Edie's been able to see the statues of London moving when no one else can. But when she sees George running with a statue, she feels some hope that maybe, just maybe, she’s not alone.

The Gunner – A World War I statue of a gunner made by a sculptor named Jagger. He has some of Jagger’s essence inside of him, which gives him a sense of humanity that the stone statues don’t have and desperately want. He’s willing to help George, but wants nothing to do with Edie.

The Walker – A mysterious man wearing a John Deere sweatshirt who wanders around London and never stops walking. In fact, he was walking around London when George and Edie’s grandparents were children, and when their grandparents’ grandparents were children. He’s more than interested in what George has done…the question is why?

The Black Friar – Like any man of God, the Friar is willing to help George and Edie. But is he called the Black Friar because he’s a black statue? Or because he has a black heart?

Dictionary Johnson – A statue of an 18th century man who wrote a dictionary. This statue unfortunately slobbers, twitches, herks and jerks, and his use of words leaves George and Edie needing a translator to figure out what he was actually trying to say.

The Clocker – One of the “weirded,” a being who used to be a man, but has been cursed to remain neither living nor dead for eternity. He is not a slave to the stone, as some of the other weirded are. But can he be trusted?