Sunday, March 22, 2009

Gullstruck Island - Book Review


Gullstruck Island
By Frances Hardinge
Macmillan Children’s Books
2009


Dedication: To my sister Sophie, a truer traveler than I shall ever be, who saved lives when others were seeing sights, and who brought back tropical diseases and broken bones instead of photos and souvenir hats

Target Age Group: Girls, 10 – 15 years old

Must Read
Good Read
Should Read

Synopsis

13 year old Arilou is a member of the Lace tribe, the indigenous tribe of Gullstruck Island, a tribe that is not trusted by any of the other settlers who live on the island.

But Arilou is also a Lost, which means that she can send her senses away from her body to see or hear events elsewhere on the island. A Lost is revered, and people come from miles around to see Arilou. Their visits provide her poverty-stricken village of Hollow Beasts with enough food and goods to survive, and keep them safe from the suspicious whispers of the surrounding non-Lace villagers.

But there’s a problem. Maybe Arilou isn’t Lost at all, maybe she’s really just an imbecile, something her entire village of Hollow Beasts suspects.

Arilou is cared for by her younger sister, 12 year old Hathin. Hathin interprets Arilou’s mutterings for the people who come to visit.

Life at Hollow Beasts takes a radical turn when Raglan Skein, a Lost Inspector, comes to the village to test Arilou. If he finds that Arilou is not a Lost, then Hollow Beasts will not survive. The entire village is depending on Hathin to deceive Inspector Skein so that Arilou passes the test.

But tragedy strikes during Inspector Skein’s visit. Is it murder? Natural death? Coincidence? Or conspiracy?

Suddenly, Hathin and Arilou are plunged into chaos and become the central figures of island-wide hunt. Because if Arilou really is a Lost, she might know what the truth is.


Book Review

Gullstruck Island is a slow-starting book. The first few chapters spend a considerable amount of time describing the history of the island, the people who live on it, the relationships between its inhabitants and the languages they speak. It goes into great detail about each group’s customs and habits, which are vastly different. And it introduces a number of characters – a LOT of characters, whom I had trouble keeping straight.

I started reading Gullstruck Island right after Eon Dragoneye Reborn, which captured me from the first page, and I was pretty disappointed at this book’s slow pace.

But I’m glad I stayed with it. Once past the history lesson, the story is rich, complex and surprising. For me, the true enjoyment of the book started around Chapter 8. After Chapter 12, I was hooked and found it hard to put the book down.

The complexity of Gullstruck Island’s story is similar to Ms. Hardinge’s first book, Fly By Night (which remains one of my favorites), in that there is more than one force at play, and the bad seed at the root of the trouble is not at all what I expected. If you’re willing to wade through a muddish start, then this book delivers a very good story.

Characters

Hathin – 12 years old, and the heroine of the story. She is Arilou’s little sister, whose sole purpose for living to is to take care of her sister and perpetuate the belief that Arilou is a Lost. Hathin is a Lace, with a trace of pirate in her ancestry.

Arilou – 13 years old, and the Lady Lost of Hollow Beasts. Although Arilou showed signs of being a Lost as an infant, they disappeared without a trace. In spite of years or trying, Hathin has never been able to make sense of Arilou’s mutterings.

Raglan Skein – The inspector who comes to Hollow Beasts to test Arilou. He is a Lost, of mixed heritage, but more of the Cavalcaste blood than Lace. He is also on the Lost Council, the body that governs all the Lost. He fears a dangerous conspiracy. Is that why he’s testing Arilou? Or is there some other reason?

Minchard Prox – The official governmental aide to Inspector Skein, of Cavalcaste descent. Like many of the Cavalcaste clans, he is extremely suspicious of the Lace. He wants to test Arilou and leave Hollow Beasts as soon as possible. But fate has other plans for him.

Whish – A member of the Lace tribe in Hollow Beasts. Whish holds a grudge against Hathin & Arilou’s family. Is it enough for her to betray them?

Larsh – A Lace master craftsman. Like all Lace in Hollow Beasts, he knows that Arilou may not be a Lost. But he too has a secret that has been well-hidden.

Therrot – Whish’s son. He left Hollow Beasts two years earlier on a revenge quest, persuaded by Hathin’s oldest sister, and has not been seen or heard from since.

Milady Page – She is the Lady Lost in the nearby village of Sweetwater. She is Cavelcaste, and constantly sending her senses out and returning with news from other villages. Like others, she is suspicious of the Lace, and she tells them she's keeping an eye on them. Is is possible that she know about Arilou?

Jimboly – Not Lace, not Cavalcaste, but a mixture of other races, Jimboly is a dentist. She pulls teeth for free, keeping the teeth themselves as payment. Unlike most non-Lace, she actually smiles, and when she smiles, it’s impossible not to like her. But why does she keep a bird tethered to her at all times?

Brendril – An Ashwalker, descended from the tribe of Dancing Steam. They get their powers by dying their clothes with the ashes of the dead. They are deadly hunters who never, ever give up, once they’ve been given a commission to hunt a murderer.

Dance – Leader of the Reckoning, a band of Lost who have taken revenge oaths when the Cavalcaste government fails to provide justice to Lace. Therrot left Hollow Beasts to join the Reckoning to seek revenge for his little sister’s death.

Superior Pedron Sun-Sedrollo – The Cavalcaste Superior of the town of Jealousy, whose sole purpose in life is to make sure his dead ancestors have everything they need. But what does this have to do with the Lace or the Lost?

Friday, March 13, 2009

Eon Dragoneye Reborn - Book Review


Eon Dragoneye Reborn
By Alison Goodman
Penguin Group
2008
Note: This book has also been published under these two titles:
The Two Pearls of Wisdom (Australia)
Eon: Rise of the Dragoneye (U.K.)


Dedication: For my dear friend Karen McKenzie

Target Age Group: Girls, 12 and older

Must Read
Good Read
Should Read

Synopsis

The Empire of the Celestial Dragons is protected by the twelve energy dragons of good fortune, each dragon guided by its Dragoneye – the dragon’s human bond. The coming year is the year of the Rat Dragon. At the new year, the ascendant dragon selects an apprentice for its Dragoneye from twelve candidates, all boys, all twelve years old, and all who can see an energy dragon.

Eon is one of these candidates. To see an energy dragon is a rare ability, and Eon has the even rarer ability to see all twelve energy dragons. But Eon is not a twelve year old boy, he is really Eona, a sixteen year old girl. She has been training with her master for the past four years for the chance to become a Dragoneye apprentice. If anyone finds out that she is female, Eona and her master will be killed without mercy.

But there is much more at stake than Eona’s life. The emperor is dying. His half-brother covets the throne over the emperor’s son. And the Rat Dragon’s Dragoneye has ambitions of his own. Eon/Eona is plunged into a world of intrigue and betrayal that is far different from what she expected, and future of the royal empire is thrust upon her shoulders, that is, upon the boy Eon’s shoulders.

Book Review

I had forgotten that I had bought this book. When I found it, I decided to read the first couple of paragraphs to decide when I would read the entire book. 10 pages later, I realized I wouldn’t be putting it down any time soon.

In short, I loved it!

Eon Dragoneye Reborn captured my imagination from the first page and kept it throughout the entire book. It is well written in first person from Eon/Eona’s perspective. It immerses the reader into a world of rich culture and mysterious heritage. It is a daring adventure with lots of twists, turns, and “all is lost” moments.

Eon Dragoneye Reborn is the first book of a two-part series. And I, for one, am anxiously awaiting the sequel!

Parental Caution

This book deals with concubines, eunichs, and a contraire (a man who lives as a woman). The concubines and eunichs are an accepted part of the rich culture within this book, as they have been in actual cultures past. The contraire is accepted in other tribes within the fictional landscape of the story.

There are two scenes in which a character tries to force himself onto Eona. These are very well written, but this is an adult topic.

Make sure your child is old enough to understand and handle these concepts before she reads the book.

Characters

Eon/Eona – Eona is a 16 year old girl posing as Eon, a 12 year old boy. She was injured several years ago and is now lame. She has pushed her feminine side away for the chance to become a Dragoneye apprentice.

Dillon – Next to Eon, the weakest candidate to be a Dragoneye apprentice. Eon and Dillon are friends, and both know that they’re not likely to be chosen as the apprentice, and yet, they both hope that they are.

Lord Brannon – Eon’s master. He is the retired Tiger Dragon’s Dragoneye. He has been sponsoring apprentice candidates in each of the past three years, all of whom have failed. Eon is his last hope. If Eon fails, Lord Brannon will be financially ruined.

Lord Ido – The current Rat Dragon’s Dragoneye. He has selected the boy he wants to be his apprentice, and it’s not Eon. Can Lord Ido influence the Rat Dragon’s decision?

Prince Kygo – 18 years old and the heir to the imperial throne. He has lived a sheltered life among the emperor’s harem. If his father dies, will he be strong enough to claim the throne?

High Lord Sethon – The emperor’s half-brother, the son of a concubine. He is not an heir to the throne, but that doesn’t stop him from wanting it. What would he do to take it?

Lady Dela – A contraire, which means he is a man who lives as a woman. In Lady Dela’s tribe, this is an honored position, but many people in the imperial court view her as a demon.

Ryko – A eunich, he has been made Lady Dela’s bodyguard. But is that his sole position? Or does he have other loyalties?

Saturday, March 7, 2009

Dragon Flight - Book Review


Dragon Flight
By Jessica Day George
Bloomsbury U.S.A. Children’s Books
2008

Dedication: For my own curious little monkey, who already loves books and whose naps made it possible for this one to be written

Target Age Group: Girls, ages 10 through 14

Must Read
Good Read
Should Read

Synopsis

Creel was named Heroine of the Dragon Wars for her help in saving Feravel in the book, Dragon Slippers. As her reward, she got her heart’s desire – not marriage to Crown Prince Miles, but her own dress shop!

She is very happy. That is, until she gets news from her good friend, Prince Luka, that the neighboring country of Citatie has declared war on Feravel. And their soldiers are all mounted on dragons.

Creel is brought into King Caxel’s council as the “dragon expert.” But can she persuade the dragons to help them? After all, dragons don’t want to get involved with human affairs. But if that’s true, then why are the dragon’s helping the soldiers of Citatie?

None of it makes sense, but all of it makes for an unforgettable adventure.

Book Review

The first story, Dragon Slippers, was such a perfect story – beginning, middle, end – that I wasn’t sure what a sequel would be like, although I liked the characters in Dragon Slippers and was happy to get reacquainted with them. Still, I was a bit skeptical about whether this would be a good story.

I quickly realized that I was wrong. Dragon Flight was just as enjoyable as Dragon Slippers.

As with Dragon Slippers, Dragon Flight is told in first person from Creel’s point of view. She’s just as outspoken in this adventure as she was in Dragon Slippers. Only this time, the stakes are higher.

Characters

Creelisel Carlbrun (Creel) – Creel is another year older and another year wiser. She owns her dress shop, a dream come true for her. But her friendship with the dragons makes her exceptionally valuable to King Caxel.

Prince Luka – The younger son of King Caxel. He’s about Creel’s age, and her good friend. Maybe even her boyfriend? He writes her frequently while he is in Citatie as Feravel’s envoy.

Shardas and Velika – King and queen of the dragons. Everyone thinks they are dead, everyone except Creel, Luka and Marta.

Amacarin, Finiul and Niva – Three dragons who are loyal to King Shardas and Queen Velika. None of them are interested in helping humans in their war.

Earl Sarryck – The commander of the Feravelan army, he doesn’t believe that the dragons are more than ignorant beasts, and the best way to deal with them is to exterminate them. But can he persuade King Caxel?

King Nason – King of Citatie. He always wears a helmet, even when he sleeps. He believes that a king should never bear his head before his underlings. But is that the real reason why he wears it?

Lord Arjas – The Grand Vizier of Citatie (the equivalent of our Secretary of State). He makes sure that King Nason keeps his helmet on. After all, that’s what the king wants, right?

Krashath – A large white dragon, and apparently King Nason’s pet. He sleeps behind the King’s throne. But he has a secret, one that he shares with Creel…right before he kidnaps her.